Update by user Mar 30, 2016
I have been contacted by Newegg. I will reply and in the for transparency, I will post up any additional thoughts I have as well as the conversations with their representative. Newegg may freely defend themselves publicly as well.
Original review posted by user Mar 29, 2016
I bought an ASUS X99-PRO/USB 3.1 motherboard and installed it as a replacement for an MSI motherboard that I damaged due to overclocking. The operating system and other tidbits installed just fine and I left it on overnight to download an expansion pack and the rest of the update package for a game. In the morning all was good. I made coffee and sat down and logged in. A few minutes later I caught a glimmer somewhere inside the case where there should be no lights. One of the PCIE 2.0 slots on the board and the installed card where on fire. Yes, you read that right. It was on fire.
I knew this was going to be a longshot but I hopped on newegg and started a chat session with a representative and explained the situation. I don't believe he had ever had a customer request an rma for something that actually caught on fire. The representative was nice and kept checking back with me to assure that he was working on the issue. I am pretty sure that he was talking to his supervisor. I probably would to. In the end, the representative asked me if I still had the box and the UPC code and if the product was damaged. I said that I did, and yes, it was. He politely informed me that he couldn't authorize an rma because the product was physically damaged. Pause for a second and let that sink in.
The only other relevant question that the representative asked me was if I had followed the instructions. I was a bit baffled for a second. It took a moment for me to realize that as a customer service representative he had no idea what my experience level is or even if I could read the instructions. Fair question. Let me put it like this: I have been working with mechanical things since I was a child and electrical things since my stint in the Navy (electrical things, boards, cards, etc., etc.) and I make my living doing that and more today. It pays for my house. Did I follow instructions? Tab A goes into Slot B. Clean, bright, seated, unbound, tight. Boot. We aren't talking about doing anything hard here. It's literally Tab A into Slot B. It ran all night and part of the morning and then went up in a glorious column of acrid smoke with a brief light show as I scrambled to de-energize the system and turn a class "C" fire into a class "A" fire. The odds of something happening like this are extremely low. I've seen it three times that I can think of. Once yesterday 03-28-16, and twice in the military.
I understand that it's an electronic device. Nobody and their dog wants to take back electronic stuff if it's been used. I get it. Newegg not only takes back electronic stuff, but sells referbs and open box stuff. So what they have effectively told me is that because it broke and was damaged physically as a result of it breaking, they can't take it back. I guess it would be ok to take it back if it broke but hadn't ruined a pci-e 2.0 slot due to heat then? I follow. It doesn't make sense in the least but I follow.
Here is something that Newegg can follow: Your bottom line depends collectively on the customers bottom dollar. Had you RMA'd the board, I would have ordered another one from your site plus some other things. I was already there. I had the product page open. As a result of you taking care of me I immediately took my business elsewhere. And it's going to be permanently. Let me tell you why. Your customer service representative offered me a $10 dollar coupon. Basically, "Here's ten bucks if you will spend more money here. We won't help you but you are welcome to spend your money here." What you really offered to do was put a bit in my mouth and ride me into the sunset hollering "Look ma! No lube!".
Had I known about this website, I would have taken a picture of the motherboard. As it is, it's resting under a pile of coffee grounds and whatever spilled out of the trash bag that my son took out this morning. The best I can do is offer up a picture of the newegg receipt. I'll offer up one of the replacement board that I ordered too. Ten dollar coupon? I'll raise you a $400 dollar board that I didn't purchase from you.
I should take the time to say that I have absolutely ZERO problems with ASUS. I have always had great luck with their products. Just because you get a bad anything every once in a great while doesn't mean the whole product line is bad. I need to build a computer for my son here in the next year or so. It may very well have ASUS inside. It depends on my needs and prices of relevant pc parts at the time. This is jus luck of the draw. Asus doesn't have to defend itself to me. I'm in manufacturing.
I also don't have an issue with the customer service representative. I work for a global brand. We have policies. So does the representative. I know he was doing as instructed.
While the product that I purchased did fail, the real product that I purchased, and had for a long time was Newegg.
Matt_2016 wrote the review because of poor customer service at Newegg and attached photo s. Reviewer claimed that he or she lost $400 and wants Newegg to offer any options to resolve the issue.
The most disappointing in user's experience was having to vote with my money. Author liked the most nice representatives. The author asks this business to immediately contact him/ her to briefly discuss his/ her negative experience with the company.
Also, this reviewer considered the following companies: Amazon, Best Buy or Tigerdirect. We collected other reviews about products and/or services offered by Newegg and newegg customer care for you to read. This information may help you with your purchase decision.